Again a lot to think about and place in the right words Ellen. I may have to return with some additions and corrections.
First, I must agree with sandalfans and NorthantSimon comments; do love mj's, the fact that your SIL is trying to get you to act out more of his fantasies, and also particularly regarding the rationality of this or I would suspect any fetish, likely always varied and complex, and could have darker aspects.
This fetish mostly sits comfortably with me where footwear absolutely plays the key part, although at times of high sexual excitement, many unusual situations could; in fantasy at least, be appealing, however, hurting in any way and particularly killing anything, is just wrong and needs help.
Sex is about pleasure, not sadism for me, although in many sexual matters that is a complex issue, and even in this generally relatively mild and harmless fetish there are those who want to be hurt by stomping kicking etc etc. which could perhaps in this and other sexual situations be acceptable between consenting adults if one with a sadistic bent obliges, but not with any involuntary participant without sexual desires or the ability to voice complaint (being denied speech by shoe gag, is of course excepted
In some things I think, it is necessary to seriously consider professional help.
Given some of the things I like to doe with, or to have done with shoes, I want them clean, pristine or near pristine for the most part - no detritus or poo ever anywhere near, although as occasional shoe pee games may also be off-putting to some, perhaps a little self reflection upon my own shoe-sexual behaviours is necessary before I cast any further judgments against others.
but again, hurting or killing any creature for sado sexual pleasure is just wrong.
Reference your SIL and the videos etc that is very hard. I can understand your fears about your daughter or others finding out but as for getting rid of them, do you think he would just stop and not get others? The drive for these behaviours has at its core the most basic and strongest primal urge; the drive for sexual satisfaction, and in whichever individual variant that is manifest, it would simply not give way that easily.
That understood and on a purely personal sexual level, this board is all about vicarious pleasures, so I would in truth love to see those furtively captured videos and pictures he has made of your shoes, it would seem such a pity to simply waste them.
While you are thinking of others needs Ellen, is this whole experience catering to some of yours?
Certainly enjoying all you share and those things to come, but is this giving you some level of sexual excitement knowing what effect you have on those here, and why have you left the shoes your SIL used uncleaned?
Apologies for the length of this reply, but your circumstances, your questions and comments, have caused me a lot of thought.
Ho humm, it really is quite a complex, complex - although perhaps not quite as complex as Oedipus's !
Thanks to Freud and Tom
w.youtube.com/watch?v=mScdJURKGWM
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.